is that of the group who have replied so far, no one is really that divergent on what they saw and heard, unlike the pundits on tv.
I thought Edward's best showing was the first 18 minutes and then the lovey-dovey stuff near the end. I believe it is a toss up and that Cheney will get the win for a toss up. Edwards needed to come in and take it to Cheney and he didn't do that in a convincing manner.
Though here is a funny picture - recall, Cheney said he has never met Edwards before tonight....

