Isn't a pentagram supposed to have a circle around it or am I just messed up? 

Just looks like a star to me...but then again, my head often tilts to the left a bit...since I'm so damn confused about awards shows anyway.  I'm less worried about the star as I'm concerned about the pic of Sting down below it.  As you know, Pat Robertson called him the Son of Satan. 

He definately has Satan's chin,

Now there's a band name..."Satan's Chin."

PRH