Green Mtn
location: Observing the Progressive madness with considerably less amusement.
listening to: Grandchildren, the best reason for saving the future.
registered: 2004.04.03
posts: 2617
[view all posts]
[view all posts]
I think if you listen to talk radio you will find out what is coming.
As someone here mentioned last week, this whole charade is the
beginning drum beat for the campaign against activist judges.
Laura Ingram was funny yesterday, Terri was already dead
and it
was obvious she didn't know. Why funny: because she is so
personally concerned with Terri's situation(sic).
The other thing you will find, if you do what I do and net surf
talk
radio outlets, is that the drum beat has virtually the same thud
everywhere.
Be concerned Christians. And, keep your heads lower than
your ass.
March 31, 2005
Federal Judge Condemns Intervention in Schiavo Case
By ABBY GOODNOUGH and WILLIAM YARDLEY
INELLAS PARK, Fla., March 30 - A federal appeals court in
Atlanta refused Wednesday to reconsider the case of Terri Schiavo,
with one of the judges rebuking President Bush and Congress for
acting "in a manner demonstrably at odds with our founding
fathers' blueprint for the governance of a free people."
Outside the hospice where Ms. Schiavo has gone almost
two
weeks without her feeding tube, the mood was quieter than in
recent days. At one point her father, Robert Schindler, emerged to
say that Ms. Schiavo looked good, given the circumstances, but the
Rev. Jesse Jackson, who met with her parents for the second day in
a row, later said he was urging them to accept her probably
imminent death.
"They're hoping against hope but they know that you
cannot
live without food and water," Mr. Jackson said in an interview.
"They are looking for every spark in the dark that could be her
light. But these are very mature people, and they are looking at her
real-life options."
Mr. Schindler and his wife, Mary, had asked the full United
States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit on Wednesday to
consider ordering their daughter's feeding tube reinserted. A
three-judge panel declined to issue such an order last Friday, and
after less than day's deliberation, the full court issued a 10-to-2
decision rejecting the latest request.
An emergency appeal the Schindlers filed with the
Supreme
Court Wednesday night, asking that Ms. Schiavo's feeding tube be
reinserted while they made further appeals, was rejected. It was the
sixth time the court declined to intervene.
The 11th Circuit court's decision, signed by Chief Judge J.
L.
Edmondson, was only a sentence long. But in a concurring opinion,
Judge Stanley F. Birch Jr., appointed by the first President Bush in
1990, wrote that federal courts had no jurisdiction in the case and
that the law enacted by Congress and President Bush allowing the
Schindlers to seek a federal court review was unconstitutional.
"When the fervor of political passions moves the executive
and
legislative branches to act in ways inimical to basic constitutional
principles, it is the duty of the judiciary to intervene," wrote Judge
Birch, who has a reputation as consistently conservative. "If
sacrifices to the independence of the judiciary are permitted today,
precedent is established for the constitutional transgressions of
tomorrow."
Judge Birch said he had not had time before now to
consider
the constitutionality of the law, which Congress passed and Mr.
Bush signed before dawn March 21, because of "the rapid
developments and sensitivities in this case." The 11th Circuit court
considered and rejected several
appeals from the Schindlers last week after Judge James D.
Whittemore of Federal District Court in Tampa denied their
motions.
In particular, Judge Birch wrote, a provision of the new
law
requiring a fresh federal review of all the evidence presented in the
case made it unconstitutional. Because that provision constitutes
"legislative dictation of how a federal court should exercise its
judicial functions," he wrote, it "invades the province of the
judiciary and violates the separation of powers principle."
David J. Garrow, a legal historian at Emory University who
closely follows the 11th Circuit, said Judge Birch's opinion was
striking because the judge was a conservative Republican,
especially regarding social issues. Judge Birch wrote the ruling for
a three-judge panel of the court last year unanimously upholding a
Florida law that prohibits gay men and lesbians from adopting
children.
"This is a Republican judge going out of his way to
directly
criticize the Congress and President Bush for what they've done,"
Mr. Garrow said.
Erwin Chemerinsky, a law professor at Duke University,
said
Judge Birch probably felt it important to address the
constitutionality of the law because the opportunity might never
arise again.
"When Terri Schiavo dies, this law expires because it was
only
about her," Mr. Chemerinsky said. "This raised an important
constitutional issue that could come up again, and he's saying it's
important that some judge be on the record about it."
Mr. Jackson returned to Woodside Hospice in Pinellas Park
after
meeting with Gov. Jeb Bush and state lawmakers earlier in
Tallahassee. There, he pressed lawmakers to reconsider legislation
the State Senate rejected last week that would outlaw the removal
of feeding tubes from patients who had not left written
instructions. Ms. Schiavo, who suffered severe brain damage in
1990, left no instructions. But a state judge accepted the testimony
of her husband, Michael Schiavo, that on several occasions she had
said she would not want to be kept alive artificially.
Mr. Schiavo, who has sought to remove his wife's feeding
tube
and let her die since 1998, has long battled with her parents, who
believe she responds to them and could improve.
After meeting with Mr. Jackson in his office, Governor
Bush
praised him for lobbying on behalf of the Schindlers.
Acknowledging the political differences between Mr. Jackson, a
liberal Democrat, and many of the Schindlers' supporters, he
described Mr. Jackson's efforts as "kind of like Nixon going to
China."
Mr. Schiavo's lawyer, George Felos, arrived at the hospice
Wednesday morning and stayed on the grounds all day, leading to
speculation that Ms. Schiavo's death might be near. Yet in the early
afternoon, Mr. Schindler told reporters that his daughter still
looked good, bringing four relatives and friends who had seen her
that morning to the microphones to back him up.
"I was pleasantly surprised by what I saw and
encouraged," Mr.
Schindler said of his morning visit with Ms. Schiavo. "She's still
fighting,
and we are still fighting for her."
Christine Jordan Sexton contributed reporting from
Tallahassee, Fla.,
for this article.
Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company
Montag
–--
“Restriction of free thought and free speech is the most dangerous of all subversions.” Wm O. Douglas
“Restriction of free thought and free speech is the most dangerous of all subversions.” Wm O. Douglas
G
Green Mtn
(view)
I think if you listen to talk radio you will find out what is coming.
As someone here mentioned last week, this whole charade is the
beginning drum beat for the campaign against activist judges.
Laura Ingram was funny yesterday, Terri was already dead
and it
was obvious she didn't know. Why funny: because she is so
personally concerned with Terri's situation(sic).
The other thing you will find, if you do what I do and net surf
talk
radio outlets, is that the drum beat has virtually the same thud
everywhere.
Be concerned Christians. And, keep your heads lower than
your ass.
March 31, 2005
Federal Judge Condemns Intervention in Schiavo Case
By ABBY GOODNOUGH and WILLIAM YARDLEY
INELLAS PARK, Fla., March 30 - A federal appeals court in
Atlanta refused Wednesday to reconsider the case of Terri Schiavo,
with one of the judges rebuking President Bush and Congress for
acting "in a manner demonstrably at odds with our founding
fathers' blueprint for the governance of a free people."
Outside the hospice where Ms. Schiavo has gone almost
two
weeks without her feeding tube, the mood was quieter than in
recent days. At one point her father, Robert Schindler, emerged to
say that Ms. Schiavo looked good, given the circumstances, but the
Rev. Jesse Jackson, who met with her parents for the second day in
a row, later said he was urging them to accept her probably
imminent death.
"They're hoping against hope but they know that you
cannot
live without food and water," Mr. Jackson said in an interview.
"They are looking for every spark in the dark that could be her
light. But these are very mature people, and they are looking at her
real-life options."
Mr. Schindler and his wife, Mary, had asked the full United
States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit on Wednesday to
consider ordering their daughter's feeding tube reinserted. A
three-judge panel declined to issue such an order last Friday, and
after less than day's deliberation, the full court issued a 10-to-2
decision rejecting the latest request.
An emergency appeal the Schindlers filed with the
Supreme
Court Wednesday night, asking that Ms. Schiavo's feeding tube be
reinserted while they made further appeals, was rejected. It was the
sixth time the court declined to intervene.
The 11th Circuit court's decision, signed by Chief Judge J.
L.
Edmondson, was only a sentence long. But in a concurring opinion,
Judge Stanley F. Birch Jr., appointed by the first President Bush in
1990, wrote that federal courts had no jurisdiction in the case and
that the law enacted by Congress and President Bush allowing the
Schindlers to seek a federal court review was unconstitutional.
"When the fervor of political passions moves the executive
and
legislative branches to act in ways inimical to basic constitutional
principles, it is the duty of the judiciary to intervene," wrote Judge
Birch, who has a reputation as consistently conservative. "If
sacrifices to the independence of the judiciary are permitted today,
precedent is established for the constitutional transgressions of
tomorrow."
Judge Birch said he had not had time before now to
consider
the constitutionality of the law, which Congress passed and Mr.
Bush signed before dawn March 21, because of "the rapid
developments and sensitivities in this case." The 11th Circuit court
considered and rejected several
appeals from the Schindlers last week after Judge James D.
Whittemore of Federal District Court in Tampa denied their
motions.
In particular, Judge Birch wrote, a provision of the new
law
requiring a fresh federal review of all the evidence presented in the
case made it unconstitutional. Because that provision constitutes
"legislative dictation of how a federal court should exercise its
judicial functions," he wrote, it "invades the province of the
judiciary and violates the separation of powers principle."
David J. Garrow, a legal historian at Emory University who
closely follows the 11th Circuit, said Judge Birch's opinion was
striking because the judge was a conservative Republican,
especially regarding social issues. Judge Birch wrote the ruling for
a three-judge panel of the court last year unanimously upholding a
Florida law that prohibits gay men and lesbians from adopting
children.
"This is a Republican judge going out of his way to
directly
criticize the Congress and President Bush for what they've done,"
Mr. Garrow said.
Erwin Chemerinsky, a law professor at Duke University,
said
Judge Birch probably felt it important to address the
constitutionality of the law because the opportunity might never
arise again.
"When Terri Schiavo dies, this law expires because it was
only
about her," Mr. Chemerinsky said. "This raised an important
constitutional issue that could come up again, and he's saying it's
important that some judge be on the record about it."
Mr. Jackson returned to Woodside Hospice in Pinellas Park
after
meeting with Gov. Jeb Bush and state lawmakers earlier in
Tallahassee. There, he pressed lawmakers to reconsider legislation
the State Senate rejected last week that would outlaw the removal
of feeding tubes from patients who had not left written
instructions. Ms. Schiavo, who suffered severe brain damage in
1990, left no instructions. But a state judge accepted the testimony
of her husband, Michael Schiavo, that on several occasions she had
said she would not want to be kept alive artificially.
Mr. Schiavo, who has sought to remove his wife's feeding
tube
and let her die since 1998, has long battled with her parents, who
believe she responds to them and could improve.
After meeting with Mr. Jackson in his office, Governor
Bush
praised him for lobbying on behalf of the Schindlers.
Acknowledging the political differences between Mr. Jackson, a
liberal Democrat, and many of the Schindlers' supporters, he
described Mr. Jackson's efforts as "kind of like Nixon going to
China."
Mr. Schiavo's lawyer, George Felos, arrived at the hospice
Wednesday morning and stayed on the grounds all day, leading to
speculation that Ms. Schiavo's death might be near. Yet in the early
afternoon, Mr. Schindler told reporters that his daughter still
looked good, bringing four relatives and friends who had seen her
that morning to the microphones to back him up.
"I was pleasantly surprised by what I saw and
encouraged," Mr.
Schindler said of his morning visit with Ms. Schiavo. "She's still
fighting,
and we are still fighting for her."
Christine Jordan Sexton contributed reporting from
Tallahassee, Fla.,
for this article.
Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company
Montag
–--
“Restriction of free thought and free speech is the most dangerous of all subversions.” Wm O. Douglas
“Restriction of free thought and free speech is the most dangerous of all subversions.” Wm O. Douglas
