heathcliffe
location: woods
listening to: silence
registered: 2008.11.18
posts: 956
[view all posts]
[view all posts]
Andrew Bard Schmookler's "The Parable of the Tribes" gives an intriguing explanation of the terrible condition we find ourselves in. A contaminating struggle for power has taken away man's ability to choose peace."Parable
The new human freedom made striving for expansion and power possible. Such freedom, when multiplied, creates anarchy. The anarchy among civilized societies meant that the play of power in the system was uncontrollable. In an anarchic situation like that, no one can choose that the struggle for power shall cease. But there is one more element in the picture: no one is free to choose peace, but anyone can impose upon all the necessity for power. This is the lesson of the parable of the tribes.Imagine a group of tribes living within reach of one another. If all choose the way of peace, then all may live in peace. But what if all but one choose peace, and that one is ambitious for expansion and conquest? What can happen to the others when confronted by an ambitious and potent neighbor? Perhaps one tribe is attacked and defeated, its people destroyed and its lands seized for the use of the victors. Another is defeated, but this one is not exterminated; rather, it is subjugated and transformed to serve the conqueror. A third seeking to avoid such disaster flees from the area into some inaccessible (and undesirable) place, and its former homeland becomes part of the growing empire of the power-seeking tribe. Let us suppose that others observing these developments decide to defend themselves in order to preserve themselves and their autonomy. But the irony is that successful defense against a power-maximizing aggressor requires a society to become more like the society that threatens it. Power can be stopped only by power, and if the threatening society has discovered ways to magnify its power through innovations in organization or technology (or whatever), the defensive society will have to transform itself into something more like its foe in order to resist the external force.I have just outlined four possible outcomes for the threatened tribes: destruction, absorption and transformation, withdrawal, and imitation. In every one of these outcomes the ways of power are spread throughout the system. This is the parable of the tribes."
H
heathcliffe
(view)
Andrew Bard Schmookler's "The Parable of the Tribes" gives an intriguing explanation of the terrible condition we find ourselves in. A contaminating struggle for power has taken away man's ability to choose peace."Parable
The new human freedom made striving for expansion and power possible. Such freedom, when multiplied, creates anarchy. The anarchy among civilized societies meant that the play of power in the system was uncontrollable. In an anarchic situation like that, no one can choose that the struggle for power shall cease. But there is one more element in the picture: no one is free to choose peace, but anyone can impose upon all the necessity for power. This is the lesson of the parable of the tribes.Imagine a group of tribes living within reach of one another. If all choose the way of peace, then all may live in peace. But what if all but one choose peace, and that one is ambitious for expansion and conquest? What can happen to the others when confronted by an ambitious and potent neighbor? Perhaps one tribe is attacked and defeated, its people destroyed and its lands seized for the use of the victors. Another is defeated, but this one is not exterminated; rather, it is subjugated and transformed to serve the conqueror. A third seeking to avoid such disaster flees from the area into some inaccessible (and undesirable) place, and its former homeland becomes part of the growing empire of the power-seeking tribe. Let us suppose that others observing these developments decide to defend themselves in order to preserve themselves and their autonomy. But the irony is that successful defense against a power-maximizing aggressor requires a society to become more like the society that threatens it. Power can be stopped only by power, and if the threatening society has discovered ways to magnify its power through innovations in organization or technology (or whatever), the defensive society will have to transform itself into something more like its foe in order to resist the external force.I have just outlined four possible outcomes for the threatened tribes: destruction, absorption and transformation, withdrawal, and imitation. In every one of these outcomes the ways of power are spread throughout the system. This is the parable of the tribes."
posted 2010.08.03
posted on August 3rd 2010
H
heathcliffe
location: woods
listening to: silence
registered: 2008.11.18
posts: 956
[view all posts]
[view all posts]
-
Geno quick!...the Nazis are still out there looking for lebensraum... – mick on July 29th, 2010-
oh for fuck's sake... – mick on July 29th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – messybear on July 30th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – rosskolnikov on July 30th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – Herring405 on July 30th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – messybear on August 1st, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – heathcliffe on August 3rd, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – messybear on August 4th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – heathcliffe on August 4th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – Andrea on August 4th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – mick on August 4th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – messybear on August 4th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – Andrea on August 4th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – messybear on August 5th, 2010
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – Andrea on August 4th, 2010
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – heathcliffe on August 5th, 2010-
Re: oh for fuck's sake... – messybear on August 5th, 2010
Your reference to the Military Industrial Complex, and material for the next Triage – Peter T. on August 6th, 2010-
Re: Complex, and material for the next Triage – messybear on August 6th, 2010-
Scratching my head, Messy... – Peter T. on August 6th, 2010-
Re: Scratching my head, Messy... – messybear on August 6th, 2010
Re: Your reference to the Military Industrial Complex, and material for the next Triage – heathcliffe on August 7th, 2010-
Re: Your reference to material for the next month's Cobra bill – messybear on August 7th, 2010-
Re: Your reference to material for the next month's Cobra bill – mick on August 7th, 2010
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
